Movie Review
The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants 2
MPAA Rating: PG-13for mature material and sensuality.

Reviewed by: Thaisha Geiger
CONTRIBUTOR

Average
Moviemaking Quality:
star star star
Primary Audience:
Teens
Genre:
Adventure, Comedy, Drama, Romance
Length:
1 hr. 47 min.
Year of Release:
2008
USA Release:
August 6, 2008 (wide)
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Relevant Issues
Copyright, Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures
Films in this series

The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants” (2005)

The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants 2” (2008)

True love

Couple in love. Photo copyrighted
What is true love and how do you know when you have found it? Answer

Sex, Love & Relationships
Learn how to make your love the best it can be. Discover biblical answers to questions about sex, marriage, sexual addictions, and more.
Teen questions and answers
Teens! Have questions? Find answers in our popular TeenQs section. Get answers to your questions about life, dating and much more.
Featuring: Amber Tamblyn, America Ferrera, Blake Lively, Alexis Bledel
Director: Sanaa Hamri
Producer: Debra Martin Chase, Denise Di Novi, Broderick Johnson, Kira Davis, Andrew A. Kosove, Christine Sacani, Alison Greenspan, Leslie Morgenstein, Bob Levy
Distributor: Alcon / Warner Bros. Pictures

After the modest success of the first Sisterhood movie, a sequel was made based on the fourth and final book of the best-selling series. Two years have past, and the girls are now all in separate colleges, embarking on their new lives.

Tibby is in NYU pursuing her film degree. She and Brian are now in a serious relationship. While Tibby’s still emotionally reserved, Bryan makes it well known how much he loves her. After a pregnancy scare, Tibby quickly breaks up with him. Lena is in Rhode Island with a scholarship to an art school. After attending her grandfather’s funeral in Greece, she runs into Costos. Before she can explain the reason for their breakup, he introduces Lena to his wife. Heartbroken, Lena moves on to date Leo. These two friends must decide where to lead their lives, where to move on or to continue loving the men who claim their hearts.

Still suffering a strained relationship with her father, Bridget gets accepted to an archaeological dig in Turkey. Right before she leaves, she finds the letters her grandmother has been writing to her for over twelve years. Bridget gets tired of running and goes to Alabama to meet her grandmother. On the way, she learns about herself and her mother. Carmen is sad that her once cherished life is moving along without her. Her mother is now remarried and expecting a baby. Her lifelong friends do not really care about staying home for the summer or continuing the pants ritual. Frustrated by their apparent indifference, Carmen decides to go to Vermont where she meets a handsome British actor and surprisingly lands the lead role to a Shakespearian play.

The sequel tries to cover much more than the first film. I felt that the film was rushed at times. It would quickly jump scenes to the different friends. While the transitions were not confusing, some character development was missed. Tibby’s and Carmen’s stories were my favorites, as they were the most rounded. As a result, Bridget’s and Lena’s stories were sacrificed. The audience never gets to see Bridget’s potentially mended relationship with her father. Lena’s relationship with Leo is dropped from the storyline without further explanation.

The romances seemed a bit too syrupy and unbelievable, but I did enjoy the message of true friendship in the film.

While Carmen was upset with her friends’ different priorities, she decides to make practicing for the play her main focus. When Tibby comes in need of a friend, Carmen coldly brushes her off. During her dress rehearsal, Carmen’s mother goes into premature labor. Desperate, Carmen calls Tibby. Without any resentment or anger, Tibby quickly rushes to the hospital. I loved how Tibby quickly forgave her friend and helped her in her time of need. Forgiveness is such an essential part of being a Christian, and it was refreshing to see an example of this in a Hollywood film.

Offensive content

As for language, the movie only has three misuses of the word “hell” and one ba__rd. The reason I rated the profanity moderate (rather than low) was because the Lord’s name is said in vain at least 23 times.

The first film in the series was only rated PG; however, this sequel is rated PG-13 for the increase in sexual references. Lena takes a drawing class where she draws a nude model. Since it was her first time, and she was nervous, the nude model, Leo, asks her if she’s a “virgin” to the figure drawing. The camera lingers on his physique; it shows his chest, torso, and lower legs.

Some cleavage is shown throughout the movie. While Carmen was helping backstage in some Victorian play, the lead actress’ breasts were pushed up and very revealed. Tibby also wears some low-cut attire.

In the beginning of the film, Tibby and her boyfriend Brian decide to have sex for the first time. It shows them kissing, and he takes off his shirt. The next scene shows Tibby topless with a sheet covering her. It then shows Brian with a towel wrapped around his waist. The director wanted to make known that Brian, too, has a physique. After explaining to Tibby that the condom broke, she becomes terrified.

Although Tibby does have sex in the movie, it is portrayed in a bad light. After the pregnancy scare, she starts seeing babies everywhere and asks some thoughtful questions to her friends. She wonders why she is being punished for feeling too much and wishes she could take back that one night with Brian. Bridget also goes through her share of questions and sorrow. During a tearful scene, Bridget asks her grandmother why her mom left her all alone and why she had to commit suicide. Her grandmother told her it was because her mom was too sick and too sad. In short, it was a hopeless situation.

There are so many people in the world who are certain that they are in hopeless situations. They often buy self-help books to solve the mystery of how to be truly happy. Scripture has the complete answer and is often overlooked. God has “made known to us the mystery of his will according to his good pleasure, which he purposed in ChristEphesians 1:9.

Only after knowing God’s will for us through His son Jesus, we then know the everlasting secret to true happiness. Paul wrote in Philippians:

“I have learned the secret of being content in any and every situation, whether well fed or hungry, whether living in plenty or in want. I can do everything through Him who gives me strength.”

If you were a fan of the first movie, then I am fairly confident you will be at least somewhat satisfied with this film. However, I believe this movie is only suitable for older children. In this case, the film is appropriately rated. A discussion of the movie and God’s word should be required afterwards. One should instruct their children in how going against God, if only once, can have life-changing consequences. The theme of forgiveness and not seeking revenge should also be discussed.

Violence: None / Profanity: Moderate / Sex/Nudity: Moderate

See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.


Viewer CommentsSend your comments
Positive

Positive - Well, I went with one of my closest friends to see this movie and I thoroughly enjoyed it.There were a few parts of this movie that I didn't like but I went into the movie kind of knowing what to expect.Although I wouldn't reccomend it to middle school girls (even though I think that's who it was primarily geared towards)mainly because it deals with issues that sure in this day and age will probably be confronted with but these issues are better discussed in the home.But for most high school girls I think that this would be a good Girl's Night Out type movie.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Sierra, age 17

Positive - Overall a good movie. A couple bad things, like a short sex scene where the condum breaking is mentioned but it dosent show anything really bad. And a man poses naked for a picture and again nothing is shown so besides a couple scenes it was a very good movie.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Mandy, age 24

Positive - Overall a good movie. A couple bad things, like a short sex scene where the condum breaking is mentioned but it dosent show anything really bad. And a man poses naked for a picture and again nothing is shown so besides a couple scenes it was a very good movie.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Mandy, age 24

Positive - Had fun watching with my 14, 12 and 9 yr old daughters. Loved the 1st movie, but this one left me explaining some things. After the quick scene of the two deciding to have sex for the 1st time, Brian goes to the bathroom and says 'we broke it' and she says 'how? the landfills are full of 1000's of them.' then she's left worrying about being pregnant. There are times like this I take the opportunity to make sure my kids know what God's Word says.

For the most part, we did enjoy it as a whole.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—S.r., age 38

Positive - The only thind that really would have been objectionable is the insiuations that they made. But I loved it. One of my favorite movies this year!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Liz, age 23

Neutral

Neutral - Some fans of the books may be saddened to see books 2, 3, and 4 spliced together into one movie. At times, having the background knowledge of having read the series made some of the scenes less confusing especially when new characters were introduced (although some of the plotlines have been changed from the original books). However, those who enjoyed the series as well as those who’ve only seen the first movie will still enjoy the same quirkiness of all four girls. Their well-known personalities shine even as they face more mature situations. Many young women will be able to identify with at least one character, and each character is equally fleshed out for all to enjoy.

The main theme in the film is, of course, true friends will remain even in the toughest of situations. But, romance and the issue of sex before marriage is also a heavy plotline that is shown in a secular light. Tibby’s pregnancy scare does not result in her determining that she should wait until marriage for intimacy but has more of a lesson about trust in others. Brian’s character (Tibby’s boyfriend) is supportive and loving vowing to make things work if Tibby is pregnant. Although these are good lessons to learn and qualities to exhort, sex within the context of marriage is not mentioned. The more accepted notion of saving sex for being in love is honored. I think the film does at least spread light on the fact that sex outside of marriage is not always the glamorized version the media portrays but can have some serious consequences like teen pregnancy. God’s perfect plan of intimacy within the context of marriage was not only designed for our benefit, but for the protection of children resulting in the union as well.

The girls have matured. They are faced with mature situations; therefore, the audience should be more mature for this sequel as well, perhaps older teens and young adults. One can still leave the movie in a positive light. The message of hope, healing and having loving, supportive friends shine. But, be prepared to talk with your teens about the tough issue of sex outside of marriage.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Shawna Williams, age 29

Negative

None

Comments from young people

Positive - My family is very strict on the movies that we can watch so i grew up watching for all of the bad things in the movies such as language, nudity, sexuality and even the clothes that they wear. Overall I would say that this movie is a good movie... for teens and older. I wouldn't let younger kids watch it though because there is one scene in it. It is brief but they do talk about the slight problem that went wrong during the scene. Other than that the language is clean and there is no violence and there are good lessons of friendship and being true to yourself involved. It is also funny and i enjoyed wathcing it. If you are a teen or even adult i recommend this movie to you. (Girl will probably enjoy it more more than the guys will though)
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Katrina , age 17

Positive - I just went to this movie to hang out with my friends - I didn't really want to see it. But, I was surprised. I actually liked it. The most objectionable thing was a girl sleeping w/ her boyfriend. However, Hollywood, for once, actually showed that all is not okay when that happens. Watching he girl try to come to terms with it... it was so honestly gut-wrenching. well, as much as Sisterhood can be. Anyway, I recommend it both as a movie goer and as a Christian.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Stephanie Nill, age 16

Movie Critics

“…I can't think of another film so frankly dealing with what we expect from friendship, so tenderly showing how friends can fail in one area, yet be there in another. This isn't ‘Mean Girls;’ it's ‘Keen Girls,’ with standout performances from Ferrera and Tamblyn, each of whom expresses more with an arched eyebrow than most actresses can with their entire bodies.…”
—Carrie Rickey, Philadelphia Inquirer

“…whereas the first film presented the titular pants as a force that united its characters in shared female experience, such an impression is here routinely thwarted by a fantasyland-set script that jumps erratically between exotic locales, pressing dilemmas and tumultuous emotions, not to mention has a habit of wrapping up serious situations through flippantly easy shortcuts.”
—Nick Schager, Slant Magazine

“…is everything that ‘Sex and the City’ wanted to be. It follows the lives of four women, their career adventures, their romantic disasters and triumphs, their joys and sadness. These women are all in their early 20s, which means they are learning life’s lessons; ‘SATC’ is about forgetting them.…”
—Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times

“…The sequel takes a lighter tone with its subject matter (birth rather than death, family reunions versus families breaking apart), but does so with a more adult execution, with fewer pop songs in the soundtrack and fewer syrupy new-boyfriend montages.…”
—Chris Knight, National Post

“…while their friendships are worth imitating, many of their other choices aren't…”
—Lindy Keffer, PluggedIn

“…a sweet, sentimental and occasionally funny movie… never boring because of the skill of this cast.…”
—McClatchy, Pittsburgh Tribune-Review